Tomato Pie

Even though I planted just 4 tomato plants this summer, I have been blessed with quite a few tomatoes!  I have made 3 batches of salsa for the family…1 batch of fresh and 2 batches of cooked. I have canned several quarts of tomato juice, have frozen about 8 quarts of tomatoes, and have given tomatoes away!  Today I tried something new: tomato pie.  I had never made nor eaten tomato pie before, and think that this recipe is just amazing!  Even family members who are not thrilled with eating tomatoes liked this pie! It does take some time for preparing the tomatoes, so don’t decide to make this pie at 4:00 pm and have it ready to eat by 6:00!  The key to a perfect tomato pie is to let the tomatoes dehydrate before putting them in the pie shell.  My friend slices hers and lets them sit on paper towels over night.  I used my food dehydrator for about 2-1/2 hours.  My tomato slices could have been a little bit drier than they were, but the pie still turned out great!

1 deep dish pre-baked pie shell (I used a 10-inch pie shell.)

5-6 medium tomatoes, sliced and dehydrated

1 medium onion, sliced and sauteed

dried basil, garlic, salt and pepper to taste

cheese slices (I used cheddar, but next time will use Swiss.)

1 cup mayonnaise

1 cup grated cheese

Line the cool, baked pie shell with the cheese slices. Cover the sides as well as the bottom of the pie shell.  Place tomato slices over the cheese and some onion slices over the tomatoes.  Sprinkle with dried basil, garlic powder, salt and pepper.  Repeat layers until all tomatoes and onions are used.  Combine the mayonnaise and grated cheese.  Stir well.  Spread over the top of the pie.  Bake at 350 degrees for about 25 minutes.  Serve as a side dish with grilled chicken and rice!


Published by

The Mrs. G's

A mother-daughter project (our married names both begin with G) to rejuvenate our love of cooking and make meals creative and exciting! And now that I (mom) have discovered the Trim Healthy Mama way of cooking, I am trying to incorporate more healthful recipes!

3 thoughts on “Tomato Pie”

  1. The restaurant Grits and Groceries here in Anderson (neat little place south of town in an old country store – the chefs used to work with Emeril) has a FANTASTIC tomato pie. They used to sell the pies at our farmers’ market but haven’t this year, and I have really missed them.

    Question – I have some beautiful tomatoes this year, but they don’t seem to get to that really, really ripe, bright-red luscious flavor. Do you have any idea why? I’ve put them back outside on the screened-in porch thinking that maybe the heat will help (they were on kitchen counter for several days). Could it just be the variety?

    1. Hi, Ann! I’m not sure why your tomatoes don’t have the luscious flavor you are wanting. It could be the variety or even the weather. Too much rain (or watering) can affect the flavor. I have 2 different varieties this summer. One is beef steak which I tried for the first time. I don’t like the way the beef steak tomatoes have ripened this year. They seem to stay yellowish near the stem end and have a core that runs through the tomato. The other variety is Better Boy, and they have done really well. I pick them just shy of ripe and put them on my kitchen window sill to finish ripening. Are the ones you have on your porch getting enough sun? They love sun!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s